Audeze Maxwell Review: 58 Reddit Owners Rated It 6.4/10

VERDICT — AUDEZE MAXWELL (ORIGINAL)

6.4 / 10 · raw owner approval 67%

Positive 34 · Mixed 10 · Negative 14

58 owners · 15 threads

The sound king The best sound owners have heard in this set, with a static problem in the sidetone
Audeze Maxwell wireless gaming headset, Xbox version, black

The one-line verdict

The Maxwell earns 6.4 from 58 owners on the strength of one theme repeated about 30 times: it is the best-sounding headset most of them have ever owned. Holding it back is a flaw almost no review mentions and about 22 owners do: white noise in the sidetone the moment you raise it above zero, serious enough that 8 owners returned the headset over it alone. One honest flag on our own count: a dedicated complaint thread about that noise supplies 8 of the 14 negative verdicts. Count every owner, as we do, and it is a 6.4.

What owners love

Sound quality, by a mile. About 30 of the 34 positive owners lead with it, for music as much as games, and multiple owners rank it above wired audiophile sets they own. The battery is absurd in owner reports: one had not charged it two weeks after buying, and an 80+ hour spec is matched by owners at eight months saying the same. Build quality gets explicit praise from about 5 owners, a clear step up from the Penrose generation. Imaging is a strength for most (about 5 owners): footsteps easier to place than on their previous headsets. Wireless range impressed about 4 owners, one covering a 3,000 sq ft, four-floor house without drops. And the value line repeats: owners volunteered they would pay more.

What falls short

Sidetone static is the story: about 22 owners report hiss or white noise as soon as sidetone is raised above 0%. Audeze support told owners a small amount of noise may be present and is not classed as a defect. Eight owners returned the headset or turned against it over this alone; one exchanged units and got the same noise. Turning sidetone off, or plugging the dongle in directly with no USB extender, helped some owners. Weight is the second tax: about 10 owners flag the 490 g over long sessions, with “needs a break after 3 to 4 hours” the recurring version; shallow fit drove one return, and a third-party earpad spacer rescued at least 3 owners. Arrival QC hit 3 owners (something rattling inside an earcup, a boom mic dead out of the box, earcups falling off), and hinge and headband durability hit 2. Two FPS-focused owners call the directional audio bad and one sold his over it, directly against the imaging praise above: for most owners it is a strength, for a minority it is the deal-breaker. Smaller counts: a wake-up delay of about half a second when audio starts (3 owners), mic niggles (about 4).

58 OWNERS COUNTED · 15 THREADS · UPDATED NOVEMBER 2026

The specs that matter

Weight 490 g
Driver 90 mm planar magnetic
Battery 80+ hours; about 20 minutes of charge buys roughly a day of play
Connection 2.4 GHz wireless (USB-C dongle), Bluetooth 5.3, USB-C wired, 3.5 mm
Versions Xbox and PlayStation versions are different products with different dongles. They are not cross-compatible. The Xbox version carries a Dolby Atmos licence; the PlayStation version uses Tempest 3D
Price $359.99 (Xbox version, third-party sellers), checked November 2026

Who it fits, who it does not

Situation Verdict
Sound quality is the whole point, music included The strongest owner praise in this category
You rely on sidetone to hear your own voice Read the complaint section twice; 8 owners returned it over exactly this
You play in long sessions and are weight-sensitive 490 g is the heaviest here; several owners need breaks
You are on PlayStation See the note under the buy button before ordering anything
You want the newest model This verdict covers the original. Audeze now sells the Maxwell 2 and treats the original as a legacy product

What owners said

“These are probably the best sounding headphones you can buy for $300. Gaming or not, Period. The Nova’s are going back to Amazon tomorrow.” — POSITIVE · u/9xnine, r/Audeze (thread)

“They are heavy to me, I wish they put a smaller battery in to reduce some weight. They sound great and are comfortable but after 3-4 hours I feel like I need a break.” — MIXED · u/Jord45, r/Audeze (thread)

“the headset is unusable imo as an amateur gamer who lives in a family environment. I rely on side tone and am not ponying $300 for static.” — NEGATIVE · u/JasonSuave, r/Audeze (thread)

“Sound was not the issue for me, it was brilliant. But sidetone is a must for me and the static that it produced was a deal breaker for me.” — NEGATIVE · u/Hamshaggy70, r/Audeze (thread)

Does the Maxwell have a sidetone static problem?

For a large minority of owners, yes. About 22 of our 58 owners report white noise when sidetone is on, Audeze support describes a small amount of noise as normal and not a defect, and 8 owners returned the headset over it. If you never use sidetone, owners report the issue mostly disappears with it off.

Is the Maxwell too heavy?

It is the heaviest headset in this batch at 490 g, and about 10 owners flag long-session fatigue. Others call it comfortable for its size. The pattern in the pool: fine for shorter sessions, a break needed somewhere around hour three or four.

Xbox or PlayStation version: does it matter?

Yes. The two versions use different dongles and do not cross over. Buy the version for your console. Owners of both versions were counted in one pool here because the headset is the same and no version-specific complaint split appeared.

Is the original Maxwell still the one to buy?

This verdict covers the original Maxwell only. Audeze now lists the original as a legacy product on its own store and points buyers to the Maxwell 2, so Amazon stock of the original is remaining stock. The 6.4 above is what owners of the original report; the Maxwell 2 has no ThePCZZ count yet.

Buy it, skip it, or look elsewhere

Buy it if sound comes first and sidetone is optional for you; that is the profile of most of the 34 positive owners. Skip it if you depend on sidetone or know heavy headsets fatigue you. The Astro A50 X (5.6) is the comfort-first console alternative owners defect to, and the HD 560S (7.8) is the wired audiophile route that outscores it. Full ranking: best gaming headset.

Price checked November 2026: $359.99 at Amazon for the Maxwell Xbox version, sold by third-party sellers; Amazon no longer sells this legacy model direct (its list price was $329). A PlayStation version also exists (about $299 list); its listing identity could not be verified to our two-source standard, so this page carries no PlayStation buy button rather than risk sending you to the wrong product. Order the version built for your console.

Check Price on Amazon (Xbox version)

How this verdict was counted: 782 comments across 15 threads in r/Audeze and comparison threads elsewhere (one scoping thread returned no archive rows). 58 distinct owners with clear stances were classified from discussion archive copies (Arctic Shift mirror) in November 2026 under our published methodology. PlayStation and Xbox owners were pooled as one product. Audeze’s own representatives were excluded, as was one planted near-verbatim copy of another owner’s complaint; the original was counted once. Two reviewer-owners sit inside the positive count; removing both moves the score by less than 0.1. One author, one vote. Full method: Methodology.